Elden Ring has a number of NPCs that will be helpful to your cause, and once players interact with them they will often learn that there are choices to make to shape the story. While most choices have consequences and rewards, once you meet the NPC Roderika you will quickly learn that there is only one path for you. Since you are wondering whether or not you should tell Roderika what the Blacksmith said in Elden Ring, this guide is all you need.
Elden Ring – Roundtable: Talk to Roderika "Tell her what the blacksmith said" Dialogue choice
Players must find the remains of Roderika's companions in Stormveil Castle to begin her questline. As you progress through the questline, you'll come across this choice, and while it has no consequences, there is a neat game mechanic waiting for you if you make the right choice.
Players should definitely tell Roderika what the Blacksmith said in Elden Ring, as it will unlock her Spirit Tuner abilities. Upgrading your Spirit Ashes will help you in important battles in the future and is the best way to proceed. There are no consequences for making this choice.
During one of the quests, players will need to give her an item and when they return to the hut where they first met her, she will be gone. Players will need to go to the Roundtable Hold to give her the item and once you do, the Blacksmith will have more options for you. One of them would be to talk to the Blacksmith about Roderika and that is when players will learn about her ability to be a Spirit Tuner.